Wow you never should have taken receipt of that package with a damaged box like that. Unfortunately you own it now! Shipping companies are bastards to deal with. You need to file a claim against them RIGHT NOW! Don't wait....who was it? R&L Freight Carriers?....I think they give you something like 48 hours to file a claim. I don't think Stern will help you much at all with regards to replacement and they certainly won't incur any costs at their expense. This is very unfortunate.....I hope you are able to reach some kind of resolution but shipping companies are ASSHOLES! I had a very similar experience with an Attack From Mars LE Remake but thank god for the vendor and the manufacturer Chicago Gaming & Game Exchange of Colorado they made it all better.