Fish Tale, Congo, Shadow, Bram Stoker's Dracula, and Indy 500 would all be on my short list. I don't view any of them as more difficult then Taxi, so I think you'll be fine as far as that goes. My girls were five when we owned Dracula and they didn't not have any problems with being scared of the theme, so I also don't think that should be a major concern. I also wouldn't totally rule out some even newer games. I just noticed a few Metallica's listed, which seem to be a good value at this point. Basically just be opportunistic. If a deal pops up in your area be prepared to put money down.