Buying a 4th pin for brewery- Poll

5y 95,050 2,103 2 12

I think Metallica would balance out the three pins you currently have on location. It might be nice to have something with a little bit of edge to provide an alternative to the more family friendly themes.

#8 4 years ago

WNP

Powdevil

Pinside member

9y 55,550 256 1

You’ve gone with all science fiction movie themes thus far, so Star Trek or Deadpool are the logical choice. I personally prefer older style SS machines, so I would go with Fathom or Star Gazer to give a little variation to the line up.

#9 4 years ago

Orko

Pinside member

7y 54,800 714 1 14

Deadpool would be my first choice. I’d also recommend Stranger Things as a solid choice due to its popularity. Although I haven’t played Stranger Things and am just going on the “new factor” and it’s popularity.

#10 4 years ago

27dnast

Pinside+ Frequent

11y 140K 8,596

Always go with the latest... Stranger Things

#11 4 years ago

EMC

Pinstein

Pinball Alterniverse

Ft Lupton, CO

10y 83,550 1,738 13 1

I choose BK because people recognize the name in pinball

#12 4 years ago

BWK

Krupps4

Pinside member

5y 95,050 2,103 2 12

Make sure you let us know what you decide to buy

#13 4 years ago

LHK

LoganJK

Pinside member

Southern Pines, NC

5y 39,900 150 6

Get a remake!

#14 4 years ago

KDF

fisherdaman

Pinside member

Walking Dead kills on location.

#15 4 years ago

KDF

fisherdaman

Pinside member

Of the existing games, what seems to be the highest performer?

#16 4 years ago

GAB

pinnyheadhead

Pinside+ Frequent

Dunwoody, GA

11y 119K 5,033 8 39

Heard from a location bird that Stranger Things is the best performing pin on location ever! DP would be second and GOTG third from what you don’t have already, which are solid performers. Games you have should be good ones, which you know.

#17 4 years ago

DAD

Nazz26

Pinside member

5y 58,650 221 8

Always just a casual player told the wife I wanted a pinball machine she said lets play a few games and get a feel what we like. Went to a local place Rock Fantasy with wife and kids (16 & 21 year old) played almost all of Rock Fantasy’s 40 pins. All agreed we had a blast with Gotg. We loved the music and the Multiball with groots mouth. Later that month purchased my first pinball machine Gotg. Don’t forget my family and I knew nothing about code and game play other then hitting the ball. Since then my family and I have evolved and we are hooked. So my vote will go to Gotg.

#18 4 years ago

LRP

lpeters82

Pinside+ Frequent

12y 132K 5,282 8

I like Metallica more, but I feel like Deadpool would do better on route. Even though it's family friendly, I still think people will think it's more edgy.

#19 4 years ago

COZ

Coz

Quoted from fisherdaman:
Of the existing games, what seems to be the highest performer?

Ghostbusters is always the highest earning, but they are all close. Just trying to get opinions. I definitely want something that a random casual fan will enjoy, but also fun for more experienced players.

#20 4 years ago

PSW

Psw757

Pinside+ Frequent

11y 117K 7,226 13 48 4

I think Aerosmith Pro would do well, ac/dc pro/premium would be popular too.
I enjoy both more than a Metallica. Not saying Metallica isn’t a good game but I had one and it didn’t stay too long.

#21 4 years ago

LRP

lpeters82

Pinside+ Frequent

12y 132K 5,282 8

OP
Quoted from Coz:
Ghostbusters is always the highest earning, but they are all close. Just trying to get opinions. I definitely want something that a random casual fan will enjoy, but also fun for more experienced players.

TNA?

#22 4 years ago

STV

FalconDriver

Pinside+ Frequent

9y 65,050 1,135

I voted for MET but DP is a very close second. Always curious how GB does with the just casual player in your setting but sounds like it does well for you.
I also like TNA.

#23 4 years ago

MSL

SantaEatsCheese

Pinside+ Pro!

Crofton, MD

5y 209K 9,609 6 85 1

Thunderbirds?

#24 4 years ago

COZ

Coz

Quoted from lpeters82:
TNA?

Quoted from Orko:
Deadpool

I actually owned both of these last year and unfortunately sold them when we had our 3rd child, and also before I had the brewery opportunity. Seems like a lot of people are recommending Deadpool. I actually asked the guy that I sold it to if he’d consider selling back, but he’s really enjoying it.

#25 4 years ago

COZ

Coz

Quoted from SantaEatsCheese:
Thunderbirds?

Ummm. That would be a no.

#26 4 years ago

MSL

SantaEatsCheese

Pinside+ Pro!

Crofton, MD

5y 209K 9,609 6 85 1

OP
Quoted from Coz:
Ummm. That would be a no.

Come on... it would make the other pins look so much better! Might improve business!

#27 4 years ago

Monk

Pinside member

7y 93,800 1,909 21

For casual pinball fans I would say something that has straight forward rules, such as shoot the lit shot. As much as I like Game of Thrones (Might actually be my favorite game) the rules can be complicated for anyone just walking up to the machine.

Metallica gets the most play at my house even as I move newer machines in.

I really liked Black Knight and it is fairly simple as far as the multiballs are concerned as well as the modes. Also Black Knight has fairly quick ball times.

Stranger Things is a fun game. I only have a dozen or so games on it, but it seems fairly straight forward as far as rules. This title will probably catch most people attention. The only thing that concerns me is the one where I play was out of order within 2 weeks on location. Ball wouldn't eject from behind the screen and the screen wouldn't come down all the way. This is the only machine I have seen out of order at this location. They always put the newest machine out as soon as it comes out.

Honestly all but one of the games you have listed sound good to me. I personally would stay away from Beatles. I only held my interest for a few games and the place I play only had it on location for a few weeks.

#28 4 years ago

DOC

drsfmd

Pinside member

10y 76,550 3,156 108

Gotta very things up a bit... add a JJP or classic B/W title.

#29 4 years ago

???

Greenandwhite

Pinside+ Frequent

Bloomfield Hills, MI

5y 60,550 250

For casual players I would suggest a fan layout. Approachable and easier for players to shoot. AFMR, GOTG, ST would be my choice. A fan compliments the other pins you have on route as well.

#30 4 years ago

VNO

Vino

Pinside+ Addict

8y 168K 6,127 59 3

Afmr ce or gotg pro
Don’t know your brewery traffic but both games have approachable layouts/themes, reliable, and good with casuals or players.
Go with what would likely earn best at your location without taking a big hit.

#31 4 years ago

DOC

drsfmd

Pinside member

10y 76,550 3,156 108

I should avoid late night postings... the typos are atrocious You might say "vary" atrocious.

#32 4 years ago

???

PBINTHESOUTH

Pinside member

Little Rock, AR

12y 68,050 1,113 5 7

Metallica or TWD.. are both easily the best Pro Sterns made in several years..
TWD also has very complete code.. both have several easy to start Multi balls for the casual fans..
especially entertaining for the players and those watching is the start of Sparky Multiball.. one of the best ever!

#33 4 years ago

TBM

Zablon

Pinside member

Kellogg, IA

9y 103K 10,567 11

Seems like Oktoberfest should be mandatory.

#34 4 years ago

KDF

fisherdaman

Pinside member

What about MM remake? newbies love the castle toy, always a crowd pleaser

#35 4 years ago

Monk

Pinside member

7y 93,800 1,909 21

I'm not an operator, but from my perspective it's about getting pinball to the masses, but also how can I make the most money. With that said I wouldn't typically look past a Stern pro as they have the lowest purchase price. I don't think you would get the casual player to play anymore, or pay anymore, by spending thousands more on a premium, remake, etc. Now a place that has diehard pinheads is another story. Just my thought and I could be way off.

#36 4 years ago

???

tech25

Inactive member

Port Saint Lucie, FL

4y 13,150 39

well since its a brewery why not Oktoberfest??

#37 4 years ago

TKD

TKDalumni

Pinside member

Los Angeles, CA

9y 96,300 2,992

Metallica or Maiden would round that out pretty nice...slight edge towards Met

#38 4 years ago

JAE

isJ

Pinside member

10y 83,050 1,625 3 12

Deadpool for the mass-appeal and earnings.

#39 4 years ago

EWG

kermit24

Pinside+ Frequent

9y 123K 6,538

Deadpool earns great and casuals love it. Stranger Things is actually earning VERY well so far, but need to see what kind of drop off it sees after 90 days.

#40 4 years ago

COZ

Coz

Quoted from Monk:
I'm not an operator, but from my perspective it's about getting pinball to the masses, but also how can I make the most money. With that said I wouldn't typically look past a Stern pro as they have the lowest purchase price. I don't think you would get the casual player to play anymore, or pay anymore, by spending thousands more on a premium, remake, etc. Now a place that has diehard pinheads is another story. Just my thought and I could be way off.

Exactly. At my brewery location it’s probably 95% casual fans. They wouldn’t know the difference in a pro vs LE. Also why I don’t really want a MM or more expensive title, it won’t make more money. I plan on rotating pins in every 4-6 months to keep things fresh. Stern pros have been doing really well.

Thanks for all the input and opinions - I appreciate it

#41 4 years ago

EWG

kermit24

Pinside+ Frequent

9y 123K 6,538

OP
Quoted from Coz:
Exactly. At my brewery location it’s probably 95% casual fans. They wouldn’t know the difference in a pro vs LE. Also why I don’t really want a MM or more expensive title, it won’t make more money. I plan on rotating pins in every 4-6 months to keep things fresh. Stern pros have been doing really well.
Thanks for all the input and opinions - I appreciate it

If you are going to be rotating games in that frequently, I would just swap in the latest Stern Pro release each time. Rotate out the lowest earner, and repeat.

#42 4 years ago

POP

Nevus

Pinside+ Frequent

12y 129K 6,681 1

Deadpool Pro

Fun game
Funny Theme
A available used

#43 4 years ago

HKY

HoakyPoaky

Silver State Pinball

11y 144K 3,671 128

Champion Pub

Simplistic straightforward ruleset for casual players, fun toys & gimmicks throughout, pub theme

#44 4 years ago

SBS

o-din

Pinside+ Addict

11y 158K 58,764

For a quality brewery that cares about the ambience it presents, Deadpool is probably the least uncool game on the list.

#45 4 years ago

CSJ

pcprogrammer

Pinside member

7y 102K 2,368 35 2

Deadpool is so fun to shoot. It has my vote.

#46 4 years ago

JAE

isJ

Pinside member

10y 83,050 1,625 3 12

Quoted from o-din:
For a quality brewery that cares about the ambience it presents, Deadpool is probably the least uncool game on the list.

*coughBeatlescough*

EDIT: I can't read the difference between uncool and cool. I stick with my vote for Deadpool and agree with o-din that I am indeed correct.

#47 4 years ago

KDF

fisherdaman

Pinside member

Quoted from isJ:
*coughBeatlescough*

Breweries are hip spots, they aren't nursing homes..

#48 4 years ago

SBS

o-din

Pinside+ Addict

11y 158K 58,764

Quoted from fisherdaman:
Breweries are hip spots, they aren't nursing homes..

Yeah, if I want to feel old, I'll just stay home and read pinside.

#49 4 years ago

JAE

isJ

Pinside member