Friends & Family or not, call your credit card company and file a chargback.
The card company does not care if it's Friends & Family, they will simply reverse the charges.
This topic is closed.
Friends & Family or not, call your credit card company and file a chargback.
The card company does not care if it's Friends & Family, they will simply reverse the charges.
Quoted from ForceFlow:Can you post what you received? Was there a photo of the back of the game? Does that serial number match your game?
Quoted from Rob_G:You could always report him to paypal as a commercial retailer abusing the 'friends and family' method.
But, that doesn't really solve anything.........
Rob
I won't buy either now, I wonder how much it is costing the seller to hold firm and not stand behind their product and force a customer to go online and share this with the pinball community?
Quoted from Kal_el:Upon further inspection the WPU board was severely damaged due to severe battery acid damage.
I had e-mail and texted Ray for a week. With no reply. Last night he finally e mailed me back and now he's lying and basically saying the WPU just got this damage in the week I've had it.
As you can see, he discounted the game $200.00. Not, $800.00 like he's saying and claiming the acid damage happened since last Monday,1-30-17.
I have nothing but respectful and polite throughout this process with him.
Just informed of this post..and I wont let someone like Matt Dodge throw me and my brothers business under the bus with all his lies and made up BS! We don't do business that way!! Matt Dodge claims he has been emailing me for a week?? HA BS..try 1 day! And texts he sent late last night plus an email today, wanting me to reimburse him for an MPU he bought for a game I sold him? Why didn't he contact me first with any kind of problems he had.. or even call or allow me to offer a solution like exchanging the MPU first for one I have here..or allow me to have a tech come over and look at the game, before he takes it on himself to buying a new one?? And I would not have knowing sold it anyway with a corroded board so I don't know what game he is playing..or if that is even the corroded MPU that came from the game? Since Matt has lied to me about all the supposed emails he has sent for over a week I find him to be dishonest. The game needed cosmetic cabinet work and we bought the game from a collector in Cincy as a trade. Allen and I had intentions of restoring the game and selling for $3995 but since he passed I decided to sell it for less a week later, to help pay some of his funeral expenses, which is why the 2 invoices . I discounted the game $200, gave him free $140 prep packing and a polish kit and decals also for free. Yes I tested it and it worked fine, wasn't restored which I explained to him on the phone. He then emailed asking if the Deadworld worked fine which I answered him..yes(read his post). I have since just called the collector I got this from and he verified with me No Way the board was corroded when he sold it to me. I sent outside game pics to show him the cabinet wasn't perfect. Matt Dodge has played the game for a few weeks since getting it from NAVL and now notices MPU corrosion? And here is the last email I sent him...not what he says above.
Matt, sorry you are angry, but I am not going to pay you for a new board you ordered "without contacting us first" before doing so! Normally we would have you send the board back and we would decide to repair or fix it and then send it back to you. The game was tested and did work here ..and for you when you got it from NAVL. Re: The Discount..$340 (according to you) which is more than enough to pay for a new board anyway.
So can he send the board in for repair or replacement? I would think the discount was agreed on for a working game and the reduced price was not due to a defective board but the price he was willing to pay for a working game with some cosmetic issues?
Quoted from treasurecove:att, sorry you are angry, but I am not going to pay you for a new board you ordered "without contacting us first" before doing so! Normally we would have you send the board back and we would decide to repair or fix it and then send it back to you.
Typical BS. "Well we would've replaced the board, but now that you came to pinside, we aren't going to."
Doesn't seem very honorable.
You should do your business a courtesy and just replace the man's board or pay him the difference.
Quoted from tron1969:So can he send the board in for repair or replacement?
No because he posted on pinside about it.
Here is all the emails sent and you can see the one is from Feb 1 not a week ago??
Sir,
I e-mailed you last week. Battery acid damage like that has clearly been going on for more than a week.
Again, this was not a thoroughly tested and working 100% like you stated. Which is why I paid that amount.
Sent from my iPhone
[Hide Quoted Text]
> On Feb 1, 2017, at 11:19 AM, <[email protected]> <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> Matt, sorry you are angry, but I am not going to pay you for a new board you ordered "without contacting us first" before doing so! Normally we would have you send the board back and we would decide to repair or fix it and then send it back to you. The game was tested and did work here ..and for you when you got it from NAVL. Re: The Discount..$340 (according to you) which is more than enough to pay for a new board anyway.
>
> Quoting matt dodge <[email protected]>:
>
>> Sir,
>>
>> Battery acid damage like that doesn't happen in a week. You discounted the game from $3,400 to $3,200 stated "game was throughly tested and working 100%".
>>
>> You should make this right.
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> Dodge
>>
>> Sent from my iPhone
>>
>>> On Feb 1, 2017, at 8:12 AM, Ray <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>
>>> Matt, Sorry for the problem, you played for a while now so I don’t know what happened. ..but I cant reimburse you for the board. I discounted the game to you from $3995 to $3200 because my brother had just passed away. If you remember, I didn’t charge you the $120 "Shipping Prep" we always charge either.
>>>
>>>
>>> -----Original Message----- From: matt dodge
>>> Sent: Wednesday, February 1, 2017 12:55 AM
>>> To: Ray
>>> Subject: Re: Judge Dredd
>>>
>>> Sir,
>>>
>>> The game start button doesn't work and memory doesn't save. Upon further inspection, the MPU has severe battery acid damage. I texted you a few pics, I'll e-mail some as well. Would you be willing to reimburse for the MPU?
>>>
>>> I already ordered one as this probably the main culprit.
>>>
>>>
>>> Thank you,
>>>
>>> Dodge
>>>
>>> Sent from my iPhone
>>>
>>>> On Jan 31, 2017, at 9:44 PM, Ray <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> OK Matt.. whats up??
>>>> -----Original Message----- From: matt dodge Sent: Tuesday, January 31, 2017 8:39 PM To: Ray Subject: Judge Dredd
>>>> Sir,
>>>> If you could e-mail me or text me I would appreciate it.
>>>> Thanks,
>>>>
>>>> Dodge
I have had problems with TC in the past from a restored game I bought from them and would never do business with them again.
Quoted from treasurecove:Here is all the emails sent and you can see the one is from Feb 1 not a week ago??
Regardless, that kind of acid battery damage does not happen in a week. Did you not open the backbox up to look at it before you sold it, instead having to rely on the guy YOU bought it from?
Quoted from treasurecove:Just informed of this post..and I wont let someone like Matt Dodge throw me and my brothers business under the bus with all his lies and made up BS! We don't do business that way!! Matt Dodge claims he has been emailing me for a week?? HA BS..try 1 day! And texts he sent late last night plus an email today, wanting me to reimburse him for an MPU he bought for a game I sold him? Why didn't he contact me first with any kind of problems he had.. or even call or allow me to offer a solution like exchanging the MPU first for one I have here..or allow me to have a tech come over and look at the game, before he takes it on himself to buying a new one?? And I would not have knowing sold it anyway with a corroded board so I don't know what game he is playing..or if that is even the corroded MPU that came from the game? Since Matt has lied to me about all the supposed emails he has sent for over a week I find him to be dishonest. The game needed cosmetic cabinet work and we bought the game from a collector in Cincy as a trade. Allen and I had intentions of restoring the game and selling for $3995 but since he passed I decided to sell it for less a week later, to help pay some of his funeral expenses, which is why the 2 invoices . I discounted the game $200, gave him free $140 prep packing and a polish kit and decals also for free. Yes I tested it and it worked fine, wasn't restored which I explained to him on the phone. He then emailed asking if the Deadworld worked fine which I answered him..yes(read his post). I have since just called the collector I got this from and he verified with me No Way the board was corroded when he sold it to me. I sent outside game pics to show him the cabinet wasn't perfect. Matt Dodge has played the game for a few weeks since getting it from NAVL and now notices MPU corrosion? And here is the last email I sent him...not what he says above.
Matt, sorry you are angry, but I am not going to pay you for a new board you ordered "without contacting us first" before doing so! Normally we would have you send the board back and we would decide to repair or fix it and then send it back to you. The game was tested and did work here ..and for you when you got it from NAVL. Re: The Discount..$340 (according to you) which is more than enough to pay for a new board anyway.
I probably shouldn't be getting involved in a dispute, but one way I see that could help resolve this:
@treasurecove, Do you have photos of the boards?
@kal_el, can you post a photo of the boards in your backbox as they sit? Can you also post a photo of the serial number sticker on the back of the game or inside the cabinet? And also one of the photos you received from treasure cove with a visible serial number? (not just a screenshot of the thumbnails)
Quoted from treasurecove:Just informed of this post..and I wont let someone like Matt Dodge throw me and my brothers business under the bus with all his lies and made up BS! We don't do business that way!! Matt Dodge claims he has been emailing me for a week?? HA BS..try 1 day! And texts he sent late last night plus an email today, wanting me to reimburse him for an MPU he bought for a game I sold him? Why didn't he contact me first with any kind of problems he had.. or even call or allow me to offer a solution like exchanging the MPU first for one I have here..or allow me to have a tech come over and look at the game, before he takes it on himself to buying a new one?? And I would not have knowing sold it anyway with a corroded board so I don't know what game he is playing..or if that is even the corroded MPU that came from the game? Since Matt has lied to me about all the supposed emails he has sent for over a week I find him to be dishonest. The game needed cosmetic cabinet work and we bought the game from a collector in Cincy as a trade. Allen and I had intentions of restoring the game and selling for $3995 but since he passed I decided to sell it for less a week later, to help pay some of his funeral expenses, which is why the 2 invoices . I discounted the game $200, gave him free $140 prep packing and a polish kit and decals also for free. Yes I tested it and it worked fine, wasn't restored which I explained to him on the phone. He then emailed asking if the Deadworld worked fine which I answered him..yes(read his post). I have since just called the collector I got this from and he verified with me No Way the board was corroded when he sold it to me. I sent outside game pics to show him the cabinet wasn't perfect. Matt Dodge has played the game for a few weeks since getting it from NAVL and now notices MPU corrosion? And here is the last email I sent him...not what he says above.
Matt, sorry you are angry, but I am not going to pay you for a new board you ordered "without contacting us first" before doing so! Normally we would have you send the board back and we would decide to repair or fix it and then send it back to you. The game was tested and did work here ..and for you when you got it from NAVL. Re: The Discount..$340 (according to you) which is more than enough to pay for a new board anyway.
Ray,
Read my own e-mails! You're simply not tell the truth! Now you're saying I've secretly replaced the boards?! If there was an issue with e-mail, ok. But even TODAY you said you wouldn't reimburse me.
I waited and was patient. You also said the game was "thoroughly tested and 100%". It clearly wasn't. With that price, I figured it would be.
Bottom line the board is bad. I asked you to reimburse me and you said no. You also suggested this damage happened in a weeks time. Again read your own responses. I could've easily cancelled the new CPU order and worked something out. Which is what I wanted to do.
I didn't just whine and cry and go directly to pinside. I waited and tried to work it out. YOU said no. YOU said it was100%.
It clearly wasn't!
I am new at this and just enjoy pinball. Didn't want a fight or disagreement. Just wanted what I paid for and for $3,200 I clearly didn't get it!
Again look at your own e-mails!
Quoted from treasurecove:Just informed of this post..and I wont let someone like Matt Dodge throw me and my brothers business under the bus with all his lies and made up BS! We don't do business that way!!
Seems a little defensive. Just saying.
Don't know who Ray is, but Allen Shope was the main man there and he passed away last year. Allen would have never let that go out the door.
Quoted from Rob_G:You could always report him to paypal as a commercial retailer abusing the 'friends and family' method.
But, that doesn't really solve anything.........
Rob
I think that is worth doing.
Retailers should not be trying to avoid fees by using "family and friends".
Buyers shouldn't do it either, for that matter.
Quoted from mnpinball:Don't know who Ray is, but Allen Shope was the main man there and he passed away last year. Allen would have never let that go out the door.
Ray is his brother.
. or even call or allow me to offer a solution like exchanging the MPU first for one I have here..
so give him a board for exchange and solve the issue?
Quoted from ForceFlow:I probably shouldn't be getting involved in a dispute, but one way I see that could help resolve this:
treasurecove, Do you have photos of the boards?
kal_el, can you post a photo of the boards in your backbox as they sit? Can you also post a photo of the serial number sticker on the back of the game or inside the cabinet? And also one of the photos you received from treasure cove with a visible serial number?
I never got one with a visible serial number I don't think but I'll check. Hope the picture I just took is the serial number. If not, tell me where it's at and I'll get it.
I'll try and post the original pictures he sent me.
Quoted from ForceFlow:I probably shouldn't be getting involved in a dispute, but one way I see that could help resolve this:
treasurecove, Do you have photos of the boards?
kal_el, can you post a photo of the boards in your backbox as they sit? Can you also post a photo of the serial number sticker on the back of the game or inside the cabinet? And also one of the photos you received from treasure cove with a visible serial number?
He's you're brother?! Soooooo I see how this is going to go.
Quoted from Kal_el:He's you're brother?! Soooooo I see how this is going to go.
Allen and Ray are brothers. I don't have a stake in the matter.
Yeah that's all I've got. That one inside the backbox. There's aUPC number on the play field? That it?
Quoted from Kal_el:He's you're brother?! Soooooo I see how this is going to go.
You're loaded for bear and aiming in the wrong direction. Simma down. Forceflow, (and most of everyone in this thread) is in agreement with you.
Quoted from Kal_el:Yeah that's all I've got. That one inside the backbox. There's aUPC number on the play field? That it?
That sticker forceflow posted should be on the back of the cabinet and on the inside the cabinet on the left wall near the service box.
Thanks. Need that. And sorry moderator dude. But being called a liar with e mails and photos RIGHT HERE got me revved up.
Whoever is right or wrong here, Trasurecove shouldn't be posting responses like this on a public forum. Not a good idea. The right thing to do is post a non-emotional response and contact the customer directly. Take care of the problem. Swallow the cost of the board and move on with business. I personally would now never do business with them because of this. Not replacing this board is costing them 10x more in the long run.
Quoted from Kal_el:I never got one with a visible serial number I don't think but I'll check. Hope the picture I just took is the serial number. If not, tell me where it's at and I'll get it.
I'll try and post the original pictures he sent me.
I can see that the serial number stickers on the MPU, driver board, and sound board all match. It is expensive to swap that many boards, let alone find all with matching serial numbers. The DMD driver board doesn't have a matching serial number (but it's common to see this one swapped out), and I can't see the sticker on the fliptronics board. Granted, someone could play musical chairs with the stickers, but it can sometimes be difficult to remove them without damaging them in some way. I kind of doubt that the MPU was swapped out from somewhere else.
Quoted from ForceFlow:I can see that the serial number stickers on the MPU, driver board, and sound board all match. It is expensive to swap that many boards, let alone find all with matching serial numbers. The DMD driver board doesn't have a matching serial number (but it's common to see this one swapped out), and I can't see the sticker on the fliptronics board. Granted, someone could play musical chairs with the stickers, but it can sometimes be difficult to remove them without damaging them in some way. I kind of doubt that the MPU was swapped out from somewhere else.
Regardless, Treasure Cove sold this game as 100% working. And it's not. They should make it right and not claim that they would've made it right, but now that the OP posted here they refuse to. I am willing to bet they saw the board damage and purposely did not mention it.
Kal_el posted about this problem a week ago and didn't mention who the seller was hoping they would make things right.
https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/judge-dredd-battery-leaking#post-3575152
If he didn't contact you a week ago then He really really thought this out hard.
Quoted from ForceFlow:I can see that the serial number stickers on the MPU, driver board, and sound board all match. It is expensive to swap that many boards, let alone find all with matching serial numbers. The DMD driver board doesn't have a matching serial number (but it's common to see this one swapped out), and I can't see the sticker on the fliptronics board. Granted, someone could play musical chairs with the stickers, but it can sometimes be difficult to remove them without damaging them in some way. I kind of doubt that the MPU was swapped out from somewhere else.
I agree. The key is finding the serial number somewhere on the cabinet or backbox. That information will push this case in one direction or another.
Quoted from Kal_el:Why? Should I look under the play field? I'll do whatever I have to to find it.
Yes, look everywhere. Post a picture of it if you find it.
You are good Kal.
The photos you have posted make it blatently obvious there is zero chance you swapped out boards and this is how the game came to you.
Treasure cove needs to make this right and pay for a replacement MPU. There is NO OTHER SOLUTION. I would not accept them repairing the old board. You bought what was supposed to be a 100% game, not a battery damaged MPU or even a repaired battery damage MPU.
Treasure Cove needs to pay for the new MPU and pay for you to ship them the old one.
Quoted from Whysnow:You are good Kal.
The photos you have posted make it blatently obvious there is zero chance you swapped out boards and this is how the game came to you.
Treasure cove needs to make this right and pay for a replacement MPU. There is NO OTHER SOLUTION. I would not accept them repairing the old board. You bought what was supposed to be a 100% game, not a battery damaged MPU or even a repaired battery damage MPU.
Treasure Cove needs to pay for the new MPU and pay for you to ship them the old one.
A picture of the serial number of the game from the cabinet would pretty much shut the door on this....but I am tending to agree. Otherwise, this was a pretty elaborate game played by the OP.
Quoted from Kal_el:moderator dude
ForceFlow this is what it needs to say under your name, not pinside moderator
Quoted from Kal_el:I never got one with a visible serial number I don't think but I'll check. Hope the picture I just took is the serial number. If not, tell me where it's at and I'll get it.
I'll try and post the original pictures he sent me.
Third pic down.
21420269242
Quoted from Whysnow:You are good Kal.
The photos you have posted make it blatently obvious there is zero chance you swapped out boards and this is how the game came to you.
Treasure cove needs to make this right and pay for a replacement MPU. There is NO OTHER SOLUTION. I would not accept them repairing the old board. You bought what was supposed to be a 100% game, not a battery damaged MPU or even a repaired battery damage MPU.
Treasure Cove needs to pay for the new MPU and pay for you to ship them the old one.
^^This!^^
This topic is closed.
Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.
Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!
This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/buyer-beware/page/2?hl=mkgoetz and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.
Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.