IJ

One of the greatest pins of all time. Right up there with ST:TNG, TZ and MM. (IMHO)

I could care less who made the pin or how much it costs (as far rating it goes). "FUN" is numero uno and both TOM and IJ are fun I just happen to think that IJ is way more so. Theme does go a long way especially when it's properly implemented.

I put ST:TNG and IJ right at the top. Then maybe MM (I need to play it more to be sure) and TZ.

LOTR is a fantastic implementation of theme but the games lasted so long that it lost some the fun factor after a while......for me.

If those guys who made the Matrix Pin ever put that thing into production it would probably shoot to #1 for me on theme alone.....assuming a good implementation.

AC/DC and Tron might both be in the running but I have not played either yet.

So now it's TOM vs STTNG.

Star Trek!

Interesting because STTNG and IJ are 1 & 2 on my list.