Rules: Elvira
Gameplay: Maiden
Looks, lightshow, toys, (music): Elvira
Overall: Elvira
If you like the theme and music, Maiden is amazing, including lightshow and toys. I think the gameplay is up there with the best ever. I have only played on location so the ruleset may be top notch. DP ranks second in cat 1, 3 and 4. I would buy BM66 over Maiden, (so totally personal taste!)