Keep JD it has much more going on the ruleset is deeper and it has cool toys and gimmicks.

I would keep JD but I wouldn't buy either.

I've owned BK2K and it is an awesome game in many ways especially the music but its a one trick pony. Left loop to upper loop. Judge Dredd has way more substance to it.

Get rid of both
I've owned both and they are long gone

Keep JD

Ive owned both JD is gone and Im on my 2nd B2K I like JD and it is deeper but the overall playing experience brings me back to BK2K its a sys 11 classic.

If your BK2K is really nice, I would hold on to it.

For what it's worth, it seems to me JD is more commonly found for sale. BK2K, not so much.

It would seem to be easier to get JD back, than it would be to get BK2K back. Especially a nice BK2K.

I know JD has a lot more going on, but BK2K is one of my all-time favorites. One of the first pins to really draw me in. The audio on that game is second to none. So I say BK2K.

STAND UP AND FIGHT!

BK2K is the genesis of SR's Shao Khan voice.

Voices were very clean-sounding for the pre-DCS, Sys11 era.

This, BK2K is one of those games that everyone knows due to the sound track. How many people have made covers of the music from JD? I think BK2K has 3 or 4? Which is not to say JD isn't a cool game. It without a doubt is. If I had them I'd keep them both If I had to choose, I'd choose BK2K both for the music and simple game play. Super Classic . I like the dead world on JD, I've never played a super game so that might be something to consider as well.

Bk2k all day and not just because I own one. I could have purchased several JD’s in the time I spent looking for a nice bk2k. I believe bk2k will increase in price and popularity due to the fact that backglasses, playfields and plastics and now both being made. So, some of the beaters I passed on could now be beautiful again. Between the music, the light show, and the pure adrenaline rush of bk2k, I just don’t see how you can compare the 2. Yes, JD is deeper, but in a small-medium collection I think bk2k stands out much more. It’s kind of funny though. I was just talking to some friends about how much I want a JD suddenly.