Whitewater would be my choice, if you throw in an earthshaker or funhouse then it's getting tough.

What Donovan said.

1. Your trade opportunity is not clear. Please re-state it
2. Taxi is a nearly perfect, well-balanced layout with 5 long shots, 4 short shots, hurry ups. Great skill shot. Great rules. Theme integration is stellar. Only you know what you like from a subjective standpoint.
3. Make a poll with the possible outcomes (don't trade, trade for A, trade for B, etc.)

-mof

Whitewater and Taxi are both better than Mousin Around. It's fun but not as much as the other two. While I love Taxi and I think it's nearly a perfect playfield, I'd say there's just a little bit more to do with Wh2O, but I have a Taxi and have not been tired of playing it.

I vote white water.

1. Whitewater





11. Taxi
12. Mousing Around

Well WH20 is a better game than both Taxi and MA. A nice WH20 is a 4500-5000 game. A nice Taxi 1800-2500 a nice MA is 1500-2250 if you can find one. So if money as the measuring stick you may need some make up cash depending on condition of all games involved. So would I do it... Well I sold My Wh20 10 years ago and regretted it. It took my several years to find one reasonably priced and bought it again. I'm sure Taxi would stay in the collection for some time as its a solid system 11. MA may go sooner as the music and game play can be bit limited. Depends on how many other games you have and how much you like Wh20.
Regards,
Al

I have owned all three.
Kept Whitewater by far the shortest, didn't keep my interest like I thought it would, it's fun but not a keeper for me for the money.
As for mousing, if TMNT had that pf and rule set , it would be worth more than funhouse. Brilliant game design and rule set, one of the best sys 11. Owned one three time and always miss it....
Taxi may be the best sys 11 in my book. Great rules, layout, theme, art, callouts..
For me I look for best value often, I think here it's taxi. A can't miss.

I own both Taxi and Mousin Around and can't see myself ever selling either. Both great games. If I was forced to pick one I would go with Mousin for its great flow and difficulty achieving jackpots. It can be tough. Whitewater is a fun game but I'd rather own these two anytime.

I have a mousin around and a taxi....I like the taxi but to my son and myself I like mousin better. If you had a TSPP to trade for a mousin and taxi tell me where you live and I’ll trade my two for that tomorrow...whitewater is fun but I think having those two machines over one machine would be a nice way to go though

I love white water. I miss mine bad. I didn’t really appreciate the game until it was gone. I only sold it to gain the funds for a cftbl.

Taxi however, will never leave my collection unless it is to get a nicer taxi of course.

I have White Water and Mousin Around, as well as Taxi II (diner). Whitewater is a better game than either of the others, but there is something to be said for having 2 new games in the place of 1 old one.....

Restored a Whitewater keeper
Restored a Taxi keeper
Restored a Mousin and it left

Owned all three.

Repurchased a taxi. Top system 11 pin. Whirlwind who?!

Would repurchase a mousin. Amazing game. Amazing rule set for its time. Superb flow. Way way way overlooked by most.

Wh20 I wouldn’t rebuy. Once you reach vacation jackpot, then game got old. Plus is costs an arm and a leg.

The old system 11 progressive jackpots I love.

FB_IMG_1514771943241 (resized).jpg

WH20 for me too.

For sure mousin and taxi. Way more replay value.

Whitewater is fun, but not as fun as the two combined.

Taxi/Mousin forget the whitewater.

Are you trading WH20 for just one of those? If so, I hope you're getting some other compensation.

I prefer Mousin over Taxi.

I dont like the spinout skillshot on taxi, MA has better flow, MA has better cheese factor (i like that), MA has the cool ball traps.

Weakness on MA is the center ramp shot can be abused for points, but that can be fixed with an alternative rom or posts being bigger.

Taxi is still a fun classic sys11, but just not as good as MA long term.

I've owned both for awhile.

I sold taxi and then repurchased another. Had the pf redone and cleared.

Mousin' I sold as I fell out of pinball for awhile.

Both are top system 11 pins. I give the slight (and I mean slight) edge to taxi. The call outs are funny and unique. And I love the bell and jackpot. Mousin' has a really hard jackpot, which is something I loved. The mousetraps are super cool. Just a killer pin with some awesome ramps.

Mousin usually wears horribly on the cab. Most are faded and torn up decal wise. Taxi is the prettier pin I think.

I would trade a wh20 for a taxi and a mousin in decent shape anyday.

Taxi easily; It's an all time classic.

I personally would go with MA, but other will pick Taxi.

Best answer... go play them both and decide.