There is a thread about best value using pinside ranking vs. average selling price. It's about a year old but would be a great starting point. I have done something very similar over the years and walking dead pro, Metallica pro, shadow, and lord of the rings would always be at the top. I've owned all four of those and can confirm you can't go wrong with any of them except shadow ( I personally hate that game but haven't played it in forever). I would also agree that dialed in standard is a great value. That would be because I rank it higher than where pinside has it