Quoted from rai:I know it’s subjective, eye of the beholder type of question.
I recall back a few years ago CGC was selling AFM or MB for $6K (maybe plus shipping) and you’d have to pay extra for colorized display. (But I saw this as same similar to people buying Color DMD). Anyway to me that was such a good deal.
Now the cheapest CGC is $8K but it does come with a super size color display so (not a bad deal in relation to $6K of old CGC with color).
The cheapest Stern pins are $7K (?) I’m sorry don’t know the going price of Stern pro but let’s say $7K. Someone correct my estimate if I’m off. But most Stern should include shipping where CGC doesn’t.
So looks like $7K (Stern pro) $8500 (CGC) almost $9K (Stern premium).
Most people would say CGC is closer to Stern premium anyway so it splits the difference.
American Pinball seems to be a good deal $7k (Hot wheels) I’m not sure what Valhalla costs.
Not sure if any others are in the value discussion.
This year I spent $6700 on DeadPool Pro and $8300 on CCr SE, both NIB.
Deadpool is just awesome. I beat it for the 2nd time yesterday and still am probably going to go play it in a moment. It's super fast, interesting, great code, and has just enough visually on the PF (katana ramp, lil DP, truck, spinners, drops, and hammock DP) that it seems dynamic enough and not bare.
Meanwhile CCr is a mech machine. Move over GZ Prem. CCr is all mechs, toys, and ramps. Add in the beer glass (like Elvira gargoyles) and the pop up posts and shootout targets and it's even better. Then throw in the color changing speakers and the large DMD w/ high-res dots, and this game is f'ing loaded. I can get to High Noon if I'm really dialed in that evening. Probably been there half a dozen times. But the game is awesome and is built like a tank.
So if you think both are good value for what you get at their respective price tags, and if the price difference isn't an issue, it really comes down to whether you want a Stern or classic B/W game.
Honorable mention: I did get a floor model AIQ Pro for far less than NIB pricing and that's arguably the best value because that game is also loaded for a Pro and was less than NIB. I had a chance to scoop another title recently on basically the same deal, but I'm out of space, money, and the titles in question weren't my cup of tea... but if those weren't issues, floor models are great deals!