I see Jurassic Park is currently at the top of your list. And I took a look at your current collection.
FWIW, JP reminds me a lot of LOTR. Both the pros & cons. Great theme integration. Pulls you onto a long term quest vs. worrying about points. JP might be a *little* more linear vs. LOTR on path to completion, but still offers a variety of objectives along with progress towards the wizard modes. Music & callouts are better on LOTR, but movie code closes some of the gap on JP. Both with unique/fun ramps. Both have 3 multiballs that are both fun & challenging (although LOTR muliballs are still objective based, and JP’s are more points based). JP doesn’t play as long, but you’ll still need a monster game if you want to see/complete the main quest.
Beyond JP, I’d recommend you take a hard look at Batman 66.
