So what are the best toys in pinball. The ones that still bring a smile to your face. The ones that make non pinball people light up the first time they see it happen.

My list
MM castle destruction
MM trolls
SS coffin that says boo and opens up when you make the bat ramp
MET premium/LE hammer magnet
TAF thing hand (although I hated seeing it after about 10 plays, way to slow)
AFM bouncing aliens
MB Frank and Drac
While the toy box in AS has been done somewhat before it might be one of sterns best toys ever

What else?

Saw it at TPF and it was very cool. I wonder if it would be like the thing hand for me though and get old real quick.

Probably, but I didn't catch it and I'm sure lots of others missed it also. Beats bitching about stern, JJP, Heighway, BM66, JPOP, etc like every other thread is

You spent a ton more of your life digging that up then just listing what your favorite toys are

If forgot about the POTC ship. I remember the first time I saw it.

Pinball Magic also has some pretty cool tricks. I don't think any of them other then the skill shot have a ton of lasting power though.

Seems like the list of awesome toys is pretty short.

I think some toys are a lot better when consider the entire area. Like the ship on ST. Yes it just bounces and crashes. But add in the drop target, magnet which is also a lock, and the kickback and you have something pretty cool. Same with the AFM ship.