WWF Royal Rumble seems fun, and from most reports, can be had for 1200-1400. Wish I could find/play one.
People seem to say the game plays pretty well but they don't like the theme. I love the theme. When I was a kid I used to be into wrestling (as most kids are... well used to be before they sexualized it and messed it all up), and those are the wrestlers from my childhood. Big nostalgia factor for me.
It will probably be my next pin purchase after a STTNG