I concur with all of the sentiment about a deep game, which is probably best for you given how quickly you blew through SW. To me, that description points to LoTR, TSPP, or maybe WoZ. If it were me, I'd go LoTR. TSPP is a great theme and game, but I think it suffers a little on the sound due to the age of the machine. WoZ is a spectacle, but feels too niche to me, and maybe out of budget. LoTR is deep, with great dots and sound; fits the bill perfectly. Whatever you get, GLWTB and enjoy!