There's a biker/back alley bar here in town that is a perfect spot for a game. It's definitely a blue collar environment but the crowds are there are usually very chill and laid back.

So, if you were to put a pin on location there, what would you recommend?

I didn't even think about a music-based pin, but because they already play music in there, the benefit of having music play in a pin really doesn't do much.

When I started this thread, I assumed a unanimous "Harley Davidson" response, but appreciate the others, as well.

Any other recommendations?

Small world, but no, it's not McCool's. It's a place called Backway Lounge, just west of the post office.