Damn, you have 3 Richie Sterns, 2 Borg Sterns, and a TNA. If I had that collection, I'd personally go for something with a very different layout just to mix things up, sort of like TNA did for you. I like the TWD Prem idea above, and I'd also suggest TSPP or some Lawlor titles like RBION or FG, and have some money left over for a cheap pin to boot.