You have a ton of locations with tons of the games you're considering not too far from you. Go up to the Pinball Lounge in Orlando or Replay Museum in Tarpon Springs one weekend and play a ton of games and decide which one you enjoy the most.
Taste in pinball is just as varied as taste in music or movies, everyone is going to have different opinions. Narrow it down to just a few games you have put alot of time on, then maybe take some strangers opinions on them, but you're casting way too wide a net right now.