Melting the witch in WOZ is one of the most awesome displays I’ve experienced. The flippers go dead, the whole playfield turns green and slowly retracts to where the witch is as she sinks back down into the playfield, all the time crying “I’m melting. I’m melting.” Then you get the wonderful “Ding! Dong! The wicked witch is dead!” And that leads into a crazy victory lap mode with all five balls. No better feeling in the world.

When I played it regularly, I would get to battle the witch a couple of times a month, and I would defeat her a few times a year. It is definitely doable, not impossible. But doesn’t happen so often that the thrill wears off. IMO, the perfect balance.

Not from the last decade, but the TOTAN extra ball fanfare is my favorite. Plus, the display animation is great - trumpeters on the ramparts scrolling down to a tiger in a mihrab with a giant pinball in his mouth.

Blackwater multiball is pretty incredible especially on the Premium/LE in game of thrones. The start, the jackpots and the super jackpot are all amazing. Callouts too.

Jjp knows how to do fanfare / moments in the game . For me the best I've seen is when you kill Smaug in The Hobbit .

Killing Smaug on Hobbit is the best I've experienced so far, when the hair on the back of your neck raises you know it's a unique one. Gappa Angry is pretty sweet as well.

Especially if you aren't aware of it, as I wasn't, the first time I destroyed the ring on LoTR, I was flabbergasted not knowing what was going on. It's great: every mech in the game joins in on the celebration!

Don't want to spoil it but if you watch end of this video you can see it. Helps to have a sub hooked up and your volume up to 11 .

Another one that stood out to me, not because of how amazing it is, but because you get a literal fanfare when you earn an extra ball on Black Knight. It also reminded me of the fanfare in many Intellivision games, has a nostalgic feel.

Also, when you max out bonus, the physical bell on BK starts ringing like crazy on further bonus collection. Really fun!

Check this thread too...

https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/which-game-has-the-most-satisfying-jackpot

Banzai Run when defeating King of the Hill and completing victory laps.

I always Enjoyed the chase lighting affects in mousin around fanfare....

The fanfare for a super jackpot in Demoman is very subtle but it awesome.

Also.

JACK FUCKING POT!!

There's a lot of good examples mentioned here. I'll add Two Towers Multiball in LOTR as some the best fanfare in pinball as you progress through the mode. Those custom Gimli jackpots callouts, especially the ones with the laughs are amazing.

Reaching Monster Multiball in Scared Stiff and Gappa Angry Multiball in Elvira's House of Horrors results in a pretty awesome moment.

If you like the theme you can't go wrong .
Best bang for your buck . There is so much to shoot for and the rules have so much depth . If the game is set up steep it does not play slow and floaty . It has more VUK's diverter's , magnets and subways than you can poke a stick at . It's one of the most loaded pins and has the best ever movie assets integrated .

You can’t beat that gottlieb special / wow knock !!

LOTR destroying the ring is a pretty awesome feeling. I also agree with the witch and smaug.

High Roller Casino "Super Duper Mega Extreme Jackpot!" .

Thank you, Mr. Keefer.

Not a great game but when you open the ark for the first time Stern Indiana Jones it is definitely an o shit moment!!

It’s pretty basic compared to modern games, but the buzzer on Taxi is fantastic and unique!

Nothing, but nothing, beats Rudy's scream!!

Vacation Jackpot is definitely one of the best! Also love Knight's Ransom and Lost in the Zone's intro sequences and the music that follows. Mary Shelley's Frankenstein also has a pretty great jackpot sequence. Awesome sound effect followed by one of my favorite music tracks in pinball.

Oh, and I can't forget the Twilight Zone jackpot sequence!