Quoted from LordHumungus:Meteor, Stargazer then Quicksilver for top 3. I will say of all the classic Sterns I've owned none lasted very long so for all their want they really are just good old school pins that will get boring real fast. Great for a large collection but next 2 JP or DP or Maiden they stink.
I find it depends what frame of mind I'm in. If I'm at home by myself, I'll play JP majority of the time. But when friends are over, Quicksilver and Stars probably take the cup. They're just damn fun! Simple gameplay and fast!, you're not waiting 15min for your turn like you do on modern pins. That said, Escape Nublar is a game changer in this respect.