Well that’s a heck of a range of games to pick but here goes….
First, Walking Dead is an amazing game because of the code. It can also be a real ball buster so you really have to be focused and know the rules well to kick some ass imho.
Fathom is also spectacular. I still have that email in my collection.
Easy to learn rule set with a terrific multiball that is challenging to start and keeps you coming back for more,
A Star Trek Premium would fall into your pricing range on the high end. Fast game, great rules and great flow.
This game will probably tick up in price soon like the other Sterns so it’s a good time to grab one.
Stern Quicksilver is a lot of fun and shorter ball times.
Iron Man pro vault edition. Fantastic game. Very addictive. Shorter ball times.easy to learn rule set. I’ve owned 2 of them and I’ll pick up another one day I’m sure. These are also priced reasonably still.
Good Luck with your hunt!