Possibly too late, however other dated themes such as Elvira, TMNT, Wonka, and the dinosaur Rock bands have all been successful (to varying degrees of course, but none have truly bombed).

Nostalgia is a hell of a drug, and Gen X (the obvious target here) has been OD’ing for a few years at this point (I can admit that I’ve done a few “bumps” myself ). For a certain (now able to afford pins) age group, a “Beavis and Butthead” theme could pull all the right strings and be virtually irresistible!

I’d personally rather see “King of the Hill” if we are going to do a Judge pin - the subversive satire that made B ‘n B great is even funnier in KoH, and there is a much larger variety of material to work with.