I traded my LotR for a BDK. With the right mods it's a beauty.
The voice work is not so imoprtant for me as a german cause I don't know the real voices from the movie.
The gameplay is great, but I turned down the required ramp shots. A few weeks ago I started to think about to trade it for something new. BUT I still play it alot and it's not growing old for me.
So I think it's now a keeper for me. I think it's an unique game. But I won't have it as my only pin. It's great in combination. I now have a SM a AC/DC and this BDK and it works in this lineup.
When I have enough SM or AC/DC I play BDK. And after BDK the others are great. For me BDK is realy good but only with the SM.

But there is just one thing that makes me angry about it. I still think about what a better game it could have been if there would be a new update with better modes. STERN and Lyman should take Spider Man as a standard how finished game code should be.
If Lyman has not enough time for it, they should hire one more new programmer who could finish the job.