I had a choice of all three and chose the Beatles. I love the classic Stern and Bally Games and simple layout. The music is obvious, unless you are not a Beatles fan. The opto spinners are amazing, they rip like no spinner I've ever seen.

Rules not overly cumbersome (yes)
Pins on the more challenging side, with shorter ball times. (yes)
Good soundtrack and call outs (serious Yes)
Addictive and replayable. “Just one more game!” (yes)
Good layout with satisfying shots (yes)
Humor a plus (no so much)
Unique features a plus (opto spinners)
When all the elements come together for an immersive and fun experience! (yes)

I'm a huge Spooky fan, so I can't knock ACNC. It's just not for me.
Oktoberfest is a miss for me on theme, but not by much. Overall a good game.

Best of luck in your choice!