Quoted from MtnFrost:Oh, I'm sure I'm projecting a bit. I know they have no clue by the prices, and the discussions here by people way more knowledgeable than me. No rhyme or reason, just tossing money at everything. I'm speaking on the whole, you would be the exception, and you were willing to pay way above (guessing, since I do not know what you bought).
As far as what's reasonable for a rare pin - there are data points for everything out there. No need to guess, we already know the ballpark.
What is interesting is that the truly rare games didn't go for as much as I thought...outside of Stargazer...Quicksilver, Spirit, Andromeda, Cyclopes and especially DragonFist were in the ball park. DragonFist was the one I really was surprised on - thought that would have reached 10k.
Even the rare EMs like C37, Jacks to Open, Buckaroo, etc....were not too bad.