Quoted from Oldgoat:Are you sure it is poplar? Seems like every piece of wood I've seen on older Williams, Bally, Genco, etc. is either oak or maple. Poplar is very stable and great for holding paint but is not typically used for stained applications. More importantly, Poplar is very, very soft (540 Janka vs 870 for cheap yellow pine). Hence, why I was curious about this.
Yup, It's poplar. I just refinished the rails on a restoration. The wood is definitely softer then the hardwoods used on many of the classic woodrails of the 30s-50s. Looking at the inside of the top rail mortise (where the top slips onto the tenon), I could definitely see a green tinge to the wood which is a sure giveaway. Is the only domestic wood that I know of that has a green tinge to it. ( I have been doing professional wood working for 35 years FYI.) Many furniture makers used to use it for more than just hidden parts for the same reasons. Able to mimic more expensive hardwoods at a fraction of the price, light weight, takes stain well (again solid stains would hide the sometimes dramatic color change from heart wood to outer lighter wood) competing with more expensive 'real' hardwood furniture, it was a common substitute for the economy market. Here's a piece from the 1960's made in Maine that was a very popular brand for decades-Moosehead brand. (The finish would scar quite easily compared to hardwoods just like the rails on Skill Roll)
20201230_051218 (resized).jpg