Well, at least it isn't as bad as recipe sites...."this recipe is just awful! I replaced all the sugar with chalk and then added three times as many eggs as required and baked at twice the temperature for half the time and it came out as a disgusting lump."
Truth be told, game ratings by experienced players without having played that game may be more accurate than a novice's rating of a game in bad condition on location. Why someone would want to rate games they haven't played is beyond me, tho.