I understand. I do, holy crap. I have rebuilt a lot of flippers back before pinball was the $10k per game fad it is now. In truth the coils both could be replaced as well, but the bats weren't/aren't worn, it's like my explanation of why they were being replaced, purely aesthetical, is being ignored. The rubber needed replaced, I didn't want to get into the coils and rebuild everything as it works amazing as it is, so I stopped and tried to get someone a good deal on parts. Ffs.
I don't want to rebuild them now, I'll wait until another unit or 5 needs it done and do a dozen at a time. Until then, there are no metal shavings, there is no significant slop, there is no significant play, it really does play great still.
Thanks to everyone for all your help.
Quoted from Jmckune:The rebuild advice is correct. While those linkages may hold the old bats just fine, you likely (definitely) have excessive wear between the plunger and coil stop bracket that you can’t see without taking it apart and comparing to a new part. You likely also have excessive slop between the mechanical linkages causing a less than optimal flipping experience. Completely up to you to do it or not, but your game currently is definitely not playing at its best with worn flipper assemblies (which are more than just the bats)