I'm not seeing many people say it will suck. I'm seeing a lot of people say "Glad I waited and didn't preorder!" That's very different.
The criticisms so far are the voices, the clip art package, and the toys.
I mean, Gomez is supposed to be a toy guy. That's his thing, and he loves reminding everyone of it when he speaks, is interviewed, etc. So in turn, we keep hoping to see toy designs that bowl us over the way the Glove/Matrix did when we first played it! The way we felt when Frank first came alive and Igor lowered him onto the playfield.
And we get the Tesseract (which was just released on the Transformers *Home Edition*), and a Hulk that is just sort of a predictable moving action figure, reminding me of the CP with less fluid movement.
The game could shoot like a dream, have wonderful feeling shots and kinetics, with an amazingly engaging ruleset. It could be the most addictive pin to play ever made! And I hope it is! Who knows?
We can only discuss what we see. And I see a phoned-in toy design in the center of the playfield that I just saw in the center of the home edition Transformers (not to mention TOTAN, and pins from the 70's). And I was let down seeing the Hulk in action.
Voices don't actually seem that bad to me, and the lighting looks good. But it's a Gomez game, and speaking for myself, I expected more from the toys...