Quoted from DCfoodfreak:Exactly. BC its just bizarre to read you constants thoughts on what you have not played. Christ, enough folks know better than to buy a game they have not played, reviewing one should be up there as well.
You obviously have a lot of good input and knowledge in the pinball world. This just takes away from that.
Thank you for the partial compliment. Honestly I know there is more I could positively contribute to the pinball world (I coulda/shoulda/woulda documented bringing back to life the project Firepower II I picked up last year...).
As far as rating how games play, I have to give them plenty of plays. For example, I have played TFLE ~ 20 times, but I do not know the game well enough to rate it by a long shot. I can give examples of "I played it and X happened" but that's not really a review of the gameplay.
I think it is fair to make note of things like voice, music, art, how interesting a game looks to you (knowing it might look different seeing the actual 3 dimensional object in person). What else can I discuss without being a relatively large DB to my family and running away on a regular basis to the mainland just to try out the new hotness .
So basically, reviewing gameplay based on a few plays (or no plays) is utterly ridiculous. If I have ever done that it is unintentional, but still worth a verbal slap. I have been vocal any time I see one of the "too cool for school (tm)" pinball reviews that starts or ends with "I stopped partway through my first game it was so bad".
Saying "wow, that backglass looks like awesome/ass sauce" or "this sounds like a _____" is pretty fair game thanks to the interwebs, even if you have not played the game.
Just because a game looks/sounds like ass does not mean it plays like ass, and vice versa.
Just my opinion. If you said "you can't offer an opinion on a given art package because you have not seen it all in person" you would be partially right, but come on. I have eyes and ears.
And some days I have enough spare time to type about what they see and hear