Well, I do see what looks like some planking in the blue area on the left side. Those horizontal lines are hard to refute.
pasted_image (resized).png
Some of the minor nicks & scratches you highlighted do seem to appear in the photos. I probably would have chalked those up to image artifacts or reflections without the direct comparison.
The left top backbox damage doesn't appear to be visible in the original photos, so that is inconclusive as to whether or not that could've happened during shipping, but it does appear to be conveniently out of frame.
Quoted from ant68:In my and other pinball collectors view, planking like this happens over a period of years when the layer of ply start to seperate caused from a manufacturing fault.This can't happen in a 3-4 moth period .
If the game is stored in a poor environment (unstable temperature, unstable humidity), planking can develop fairly quickly. It could have possibly developed in 40 days it spent in the shipping container, regardless of what happened to other games (they weren't all made from the same batch of wood, after all).
But based on the photo, it looks like the planking may have already been present. However, it's also possible that it got worse during transport.
I'd agree that the cabinet was not mint or completely free of flaws.
Quoted from ant68:I did not claim the full amount back from the credit card company only part of the amount
I was not even aware that you could actually do that.
All in all, I do not think this falls into the category of a scam. It sounds like there was a difference in opinion as to the actual condition of the game.