Not wanting to defend Classic Arcades in any way as I have no opinion on that at all, but could that be the milky white plastic film that some plastics have on them as a protector changing the color of the slingshot plastic?
Quoted from PinballAir:Search classic Arcades here on pinside.
As an example: paid 25 for slng plastics at allentown. Bottom one is original, his is the top. Not even close and matches nothing in game.
I purchased his hot stamped pop bumper caps for high speed. NOT hot stamped. Just screen printed.
For me, if there are absolutely no other options then it is what it is.
But do not believe his descriptions.
[quoted image]