Golden Tee, all the way. I've always enjoyed video golf, though. If you're getting a -16 or -17 (starts shipping next week I think) you'll get every course going back to 07. I haven't counted, but it's a lot of courses. The game can be difficult for a beginner, but I feel like there's a lot more replay value.
We have quite a few hunters on route going back to the old Sammy ones, so I get a lot of time to 'test' them. I couldn't see spending $6k on an HD for home use. There's a lot of cool stuff, and the graphics are the best of the series. Zombies is a neat mode, but I think I would get sick of it if I played it more than occasionally. The game is the same every time, whereas a round of golf can be totally different depending on the weather.