Quoted from jhanley:I don't think I need to ask how they were.
Waters lip synchs for most (all?) of the songs. Think of it as seeing a pretty good stage production with a good cover band. I enjoy the shows well enough (saw him perform The Wall 4 times, saw the Dark Side of the Moon performance once) but I really can't justify seeing any more of his shows.
I caught Gilmour last year, I disliked like 50% of his set, but his performance was awesome.