Quoted from paul_8788:
Deadpool would've been an automatic based on theme alone not too long ago but I am at the point now where a pin has have the trifecta of theme, rules and gameplay for me to even consider NIB. Bad CDN dollar and ever increasing pin prices has made it too easy to take a bath on buying NIB these days.
I am right there with you. I'm looking at getting a NIB pin, which would be my first pin. I don't have a lot of room to work with, and I already have a MAME cabinet (which I love) which takes up a lot of space. I've been going over all the options, but I too need to hit the trifecta. Star Wars is a great theme, but the overly complicated rules and brutal gameplay turned me off. Iron Maiden plays great, but I can't get on board with the theme (also not a fan of the music). Dialed In looks really fun, but not sure I like the theme, nor the price tag. TNA's theme, music, art and lightshow are incredible, but I feel that the simple gameplay might get too boring after awhile (especially in a one pin household).
I'll wait to see what Deadpool is like, as the leaked playfield pic looked interesting, especially seeing that it's likely to be based on the comics and not the movies. If it isn't a fit, Guardians of the Galaxy is looking promising. Love the theme, art and the gameplay. The fake voices and repetitive songs are a dealbreaker though, but cleland's sound mod might just turn things around for me