I played about 6 hrs of rdr2 and to be honest i didnt enjoy it. I appreciate all the detail etc but i hated bumping into a stranger and either be arrested or in a shoot out.
When shooting in a mission i felt i was limited in how to carry it out. Open world but not open when in combat.
Also manually searching drawers, horse riding forever got tiresome fast.
I enjoyed far cry 5 more, even though the detail is a lot less, but you had a lot more freedom in a mission.
My opinion only, good luck to those who enjoy it.