had great success with rentals over 15 years, but I don't self manage (use a property manager @6% fee). I do know that your success depends largely on the area where your properties are, and the industry in the area, etc.
I saw on the news one night the SWAT team forced entry in a house, and realized it was one of ours. They had to force entry in full on gear in all doors because a tenant was holding his GF at gunpoint, high on drugs and wouldn't let her out of the house while she was on 911 asking for help. He fired off a round so an electrician had to come out and inspect the property before the power could be turned back on. $4,000 in damages that I had to eat when we did a 48 hour eviction and had to repair everything...
In general though they have been great and build a ton of equity each month.