I have had both PDI and Invisiglass right next to each other and could not tell a difference AT ALL (nether could anyone else I showed). They both look fantastic on a pin and make them pop. That said, I give the edge to Invisiglass due to the following:
1. Customer service. Jen is awesome and usually has some great deals if you buy more than 1 sheet.
2. Packaging. PDI packaging and the damn popcorn peanuts...they suck and make a huge mess!
3. Invisiglass is made is the USA. Not a game changer for me, but definitely a plus!
My $.02