It could work out. You have a very interesting, but forced, drab SW world full of shitbags, the underworld of SWpunk ruin etc. The issue comes with Andor, which has to be (so far) one of the all time worst leading SW characters. They've got their work cut out for them in that regard. Hes a whiny, dirty, scummy Frenchman that doesn't have many interesting attributes; yet.
The first thing that happens 8 minutes into the show or whatever I was fully in; baddass. Then we just got a bunch of boring groundwork laid for later.
See what happens in 2 &3

3 episodes, same old Andor. The only interesting chance they had was the empire cop was actually the small boy on the mining planet of France.
There's stupid and then there's the old "engines on the ceiling battle."
Sure sure; British Colonialism and all that.
Very very tough to turn this character around. And um, I think I've already see him be the same prick in Rogue 1 so I don;t really get the endgame here.

Oh how cute; it's a proper WWII movie now.

"Proper;" as in the drab green & brown color palette, practicing marching, little scale replicas of Nazi strongholds etc

Episode 6

Completely 100% solid. Just end the season there with a Henry Hill laughing in the shower moment.

Meh I put them aboot equal personally; Rings is much easier watch for me and LOTR aren't really my thing. Hmm...I do skip over a lot if the Hobbits parts though
Andwhore has 6 more episodes to become the lifelong Rebellion master he was in R1.

Rouge universe isn't for everyone. it's whole purpose is so the shit SW doesn't show; which is a great idea. All the casualties of a galactic military power sucking the life out of everything is awesome; and I can watch it all day. Fat British colonizers marching around & mopey fired Empire guy hanging out with his mom trying to get job with his uncle....like I said; not for everyone.
Yeah yeah I know, his long journey to the Rebellion side coming up.

Episode 8
Now THAT is a perfect episode

What if Nazis were....British.

Although at some point the Empire might want to look into facial recognition software.

Might want to try Mando & Bobba which take place AFTER the good movies and before the other shitty ones.

Fucking HORRIBLE. Just so goddamn lazy.

*Inside writer's room*
"Why doesn't he walk around the fire or like force hover or some shit; he's like the most powerful person in the Galaxy?"
"Oh um it's like ah a Frankenstein thing; fire bad because of like the lava & um...high ground?"
"Sure whatever. Ok let's work on the Solo series."

Ok just a setting things up episode;

Death Star shit you'd think.

Shows you how much better a show can be....when everyone is British.

I don't troll any threads & since half the entire show(75%+?) have British accents I don't know how that would be trolling anyway?

Andor, Bix, & Syril are North Amercian...and then...

Mon, Vel, Cinta, Luthen (swedish), Maarve (Irish), Everyone in the prison, you can go further to Luthan side kick, Tay, Sad dude's mom but I don't know how deep you want to go with main characters..2 or 3 I guess?
Guess no empire people can count as main characters either, Sorry Dedra!

Hoping Luthan was gonna have to lightbsaber a bitch but no such luck.

It might have already; dont know what he was holding when he was talking to Saw.

Yeah I never said he was a Jedi; and obviously I don't want any Jedis either. Ship already has the tech.