I've dealt with my local distro for either used or NIB games since I was 14. He's never screwed me and I always pay cash, therefore he gives me a HUGE discount---more than I can get on Amazon. However, if I were to ever buy a pin on Amazon, I would certainly buy the insurance. Face it--Stern (and now JJP) have crap "Quality Control" and rather than put the onus on the distributor for making things right, I'd gladly pay Amazon ~$20.00/year for it and have THEM lean on Stern/JJP. Mind you, this is if I *were* to buy a Stern/JJP product, which is highly unlikely given their dispassionate way of treating problems.