I get the sense that admitting to liking POTC is akin to enjoying Neil Diamond: neither is considered very cool. POTC is one of the favourites in my collection. I just did a full LED treatment with colour matched LEDs and with the lights out, it looks fantastic. It is a great game for casual players and guests. The ruleset is straight forward and most shots are not too difficult. There may be some snobbery involved in its lowish ratings: Disney theme, Stern game, fake Johnny Depp voice overs. It is a very underrated game.