The drop target boards are not wired right or could be changed to be better. There are two circuits on those boards. One is off-on-off and the other is off-on. Most Williams of that era had the off-on-off circuit wired in series with the other boards so it knew when all the drops we're down to reset.
Alien poker only needs one of the circuits and off-on circuit is best. If it is making a bad connection, a little vibration is all that is needed to get it to go. If the circuit is missed on the way down with off-on-off, your sol.