For those who have played both, what's the general preference between these two if you were buying to own? Both have great music, great light shows, cool modes, an upper playfield, brutal gameplay, and a similar price point.

If you were to choose a favorite to own, which one would it be?

Thanks guys, I think I'll go for Alice. It does seem to have everything even if the shots are a bit tight.

Already have POTC

We have an AMH at the local arcade and it's always breaking. Great concept, but the constant problems plus the laser cut mdf make it a no for me. It's fun when it works though.

Thanks guys. The poll really helped me on my decision and I bought Alice from my buddy. I toyed with getting a new one so I could customize it but decided on his. Thanks all!