I would pick MMR. I have had one for almost 2.5 years and try to play it everyday. I have only beat Battle for the Kingdom 3 times and it never gets old. In my opinion the art, theme, layout, call outs, music, toys and rules are better than AFMR. However AFM is a fantastic game and would love to own one. Whichever one you get you will be satisfied. For some reason though I can and do see how AFM is better even though my opinion stated everything is better on MM. Sometimes having less and being less attractive is better in the long run.