Edit: They just refused a refund.

I'll mostly let the pictures speak for themselves, but I am disapointed in the overlay I received from Classic Arcades. The material quality is fantastic and I managed to install it correctly in one shot (so far as I can tell) but the overlay is missing details clearly advertised in their listing. Look at the city inserts. There are no graphics in them... no statue of liberty, no big ben etc. Look at the keylines around the bottom cities... they are crooked. Look at the difference in color on the red between the original and the replacement. Look at the 2 tone color of the area around the inserts then look at mine. Most everything lines up perfectly, but the T an I letters have the insert hole misalligned. The inserts around it cannot be perfectly alligned while this one is crooked. That can't be an installation error.

I wouldn't keep this, but I'd already sanded my playfield in preparation for installation so now I'm commited and have now installed. I've initiated a refund through ebay but they want me to return the item so I guess I'm screwed and will live with it or go in deeper and do a full playfield swap.

If you do an overlay:

1. Wait to sand until you receive your product to ensure it really is correct.
2. The full top side tear down took about 6 hours for me.
3. Be aware you have to "cut this out" once installed. Count for another 2 hours.
4. Give it another 2 hours to remove the goo from the areas you cut out.

I can cut my losses here and do a playfield swap, but the whole point on this was to cut down on the time required. I have a playfield protector I was going to just throw on top and call it a day. I'll decide soon.
Color Differences 2.jpgT.png

Classic Arcades has refused my refund as the product is used. I have invited them to respond to this thread. I will be filing a dispute with ebay, paypal, and emailing planetary pinball to let them know the quality that their licensor is providing. If anyone wants to see the original ad listing, it's here. I have additionally changed the title of this tread.

ebay.com link: MIDWAY ATTACK FROM MARS Pinball Machine Playfield Overlay

Gonna do things right. A local pinsider reached out to me and I just picked up this 2012 run repro. There is a small printing error on the right side (missing black under the jackpot) you'd have to point out to notice but I'm doing my first playfield swap.

Classic Arcades is now trying to send me another decal instead of a refund despite my protest since I contacted the license holder, ebay, paypal, etc.. I got a response from planetary the message I sent is being elevated planetary is atleast aware of the issue.

With that all said... it looks like I'm the first person in the history of overlay installs to not have wrinkling issues. With that said I installed dry and did not clear coat.

20200818_192046 (resized).jpg

You live you learn.

I had/have a playfield protector on order for exactly this reason.

This new playfield is SHINNY!

The old one may serve as a wall-hanger.

Feedback making it's way through Planetary Pinball (the licencor) now.

Sent Classic Arcades a refund request instead of a replacement.

As for my for Classic Arcades and their response...

Got the controlled lamps and GI in minus the pops. Its a pain but not that bad. Flashers are next. Got a note back from planetary that the quality I received was unsat and they reached out to Classic Arcades, told them as much, and to work with me. Its something. Worst case scenario Classic Arcades only got a call from the licensor.

20200822_060056 (resized).jpg

I'm working on it. I'm doing the swap one J connector at a time to keep things from getting out of hand.

I see no reason why this will be an issue. Im only 3 or so hours into the bottom side and only had to de solder and re solder one wire. I will clean up the wires once its all in. Im guessing I will be finding out in the next few days.

Well. You live you learn. I had already done the topside teardown for the overlay.

I will put the playfield straight on the cloth blanket when I get home. The plan is to just populate the bottoming before moving it to the cabinet and doing the topside.

Less scary with a few zip ties? Still lots to do.

15981322198558547762063522859716 (resized).jpg

GI, controlled lighting, and switches in. All that's left is hardware and the vuks. About 4 hours in on the bottom side. This is going to happen!

20200823_062559 (resized).jpg

20200823_062629 (resized).jpg

I am obviously not a fan. However. I would recommend this product provided:

1. The playfield is too far gone for touchup.
2. There are no repro or substitute playfields available.
3. You wait until product is in hand to verify quality. Fit, and finish of product prior to doing any prep work. Demand refund or exchange if not perfect.

In the end I'm guessing my swap will be about 4 hours longer than the prep work for the overlay would have been.

So much better finishing the flashers and solenoids. Braid is staying together on those 15982072189107858849795804194974 (resized).jpg15982072189107858849795804194974 (resized).jpg

Here is the old playfield fully stripped with the overlay fully so you can see what I was talking about the classic arcades inserts missing art. Gonna be my new wallhanger.

20200823_150806 (resized).jpg

20200823_150826 (resized).jpg