Edit: They just refused a refund.
I'll mostly let the pictures speak for themselves, but I am disapointed in the overlay I received from Classic Arcades. The material quality is fantastic and I managed to install it correctly in one shot (so far as I can tell) but the overlay is missing details clearly advertised in their listing. Look at the city inserts. There are no graphics in them... no statue of liberty, no big ben etc. Look at the keylines around the bottom cities... they are crooked. Look at the difference in color on the red between the original and the replacement. Look at the 2 tone color of the area around the inserts then look at mine. Most everything lines up perfectly, but the T an I letters have the insert hole misalligned. The inserts around it cannot be perfectly alligned while this one is crooked. That can't be an installation error.
I wouldn't keep this, but I'd already sanded my playfield in preparation for installation so now I'm commited and have now installed. I've initiated a refund through ebay but they want me to return the item so I guess I'm screwed and will live with it or go in deeper and do a full playfield swap.
If you do an overlay:
1. Wait to sand until you receive your product to ensure it really is correct.
2. The full top side tear down took about 6 hours for me.
3. Be aware you have to "cut this out" once installed. Count for another 2 hours.
4. Give it another 2 hours to remove the goo from the areas you cut out.
I can cut my losses here and do a playfield swap, but the whole point on this was to cut down on the time required. I have a playfield protector I was going to just throw on top and call it a day. I'll decide soon.