Played both. Buying an AS. Like others, I am a big fan of Star Wars while I think Aerosmith's music is ok. AS just blew SW away IMO... for now. Music fits it nicely, artwork is incredible and the game play is much more to my liking than SW. If SW Premium comes a long way, I will be glad to revisit it down the line. But for now, I'm 100% in on AS.