Aerosmith is a solid game but I pick SW Pro based on theme, speed, lights, sound and just general excitement. Aerosmith may have more toys but it's still a game revolving around Aerosmith and the rule-set feels pretty bland and too similar to KISS in my opinion. At least Star Wars is unique and introduces some new concepts such as locking in multipliers and the Tie fighter button.

Give it another 6 months and see what people think then. I don't think people have spent enough time on both games and the code for SW is still really early and missing modes and features and they are still figuring out how to balance out the scoring. I'd be surprised if AS is still the favorite in 2018 and beyond.

Agreed on Aerosmith. It's a solid B title overall and not really a bad game in any particular way. But I also don't think it's really extraordinary in any way besides possibly the artwork. I have a good time playing it but it isn't super exciting. I don't lose any sleep over the Medley wizard mode and Final Tour isn't something that really excites me that much. Star Wars has way more upside to me and most of this is probably due to the theme. There's more potential to blow it up big and the modes are just way more exciting then just playing songs. We haven't even seen Light Saber dual or Jedi multiball yet but the hurry-ups and frenetic nature of the game just keeps me on my toes more and it seems way more exciting to play! I think some of the issues with code will be worked out and I would recommend not stacking modes if you really want to experience the game.-great that Stern now has an option to turn this off. The code isn't even on 1.0 yet and many modes and other features aren't even in the game yet so I think we need to give this game some time before declaring it a failed game.

The game needs way more Chewbacca too!