I own both and to my surprise I tend to play TOM much more than TAF even after owning both for more than a year. Also, of my five pins TOM is the only one my wife really likes (so much that she paid for a new topper for it) so that fact only makes it a keeper for me.
I've also noted that many guests starts with TOM when choosing what to play first, so it does seem to have a great visual appeal. The cabinet art is just great and the magic theme is cool so I do understand them.