Quoted from Doctor6:Hobbit sucks? I took a look at your collection, and decided you don't know wtf a good pin is. Enjoy your water world and hook.
I've never owned Water World or Hook, yet I also think Hobbit sucks.
Take a look at my collection if that's how you determine credibility. I've owned Hobbit.
The most impressive thing about the game to me is that there are people who actually like it.
My advice to the OP between ACNC and Hobbit would be to choose something else. But everybody has different taste.