Both are good games I think the OP would be happy with either one. But I vote for Metallica pro . I was just recently deciding between these 2 games (and considering the new Star Trek pro also, so I guess I was really deciding which one of the three) and I went with Metallica pro . For me it was the artwork Metallica has way better artwork . Also it seems as though the Metallica pro is very close to the same game as the LE/premium , ACDC pro is missing elements that make it seem as though its a different game then the LE/premium .