I don't get the over-rated/under-rated argument. Obviously with anything, some love some hate. I recently played AC/DC recently at expo and didn't get into it. I only played a few games and didn't know the rules. The biggest frustration was that I couldn't hear the music. It did look awesome and have a nice playfield. Love the led lighting and effects. If I spent more time with it, I bet I would come to like it. Not a big fan of the music but better than the other music pins.